US judge regrets creating bias concerns over call for women lawyers
Chief U.S. Circuit Judge
"Although I have never engaged in impermissible discrimination when selecting attorneys for MDL leadership positions or in any other facet of my work, I acknowledge that my statements could be construed as creating a preference for female attorney representation in leadership positions during the selection process," Rodgers said in a letter.
At least 78 lawsuits so far have been consolidated before
Rodgers alleging that
During a
A subsequent order stated that the judge "prefers a balanced leadership team that reflects diversity of all types and, in particular, leadership should reflect the diversity of the individual plaintiffs."
Davis argued those statements by the judge, an appointee of
Republican President
Pryor, a conservative and fellow appointee of Bush, said the judicial code of conduct and the U.S. Constitution bar judges from engaging in sex-based discrimination, including by giving preferences to lawyers for leadership positions based on sex.
He pointed to a statement conservative
Alito at the time took issue with the "unique" practice
now-deceased U.S. District Judge
Pryor said that what had been a "unique" practice "has since been touted as a 'best practice' in multidistrict litigation," as "commentators openly encourage judges who preside over these actions to consider impermissible characteristics."
But he said the complaint against Rodgers should be dismissed after she acknowledged the concerns created by her statements and took steps to address them.
Following Davis' complaint, Rodgers issued a new order making clear any attorney could apply to lead the MDL, without any reference to their sex. She told applicants she would consider them solely on "individual merit."
Davis in a statement on Friday called the decision "a
victory for judicial integrity."
(Reporting by
(c) Reuters 2025. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by caching, framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters and the Reuters sphere logo are registered trademarks and trademarks of the Reuters group of companies around the world.

Related News
-
Exclusive-Rapid7 nears settlement with activist Jana Partners, sources say
Reuters - 43 minutes ago
-
Conan O'Brien receives Mark Twain humor prize at revamped Kennedy Center
Reuters - 5:48 PM ET 3/23/2025
-
Australia's James Hardie to acquire US-based AZEK in $8.8 billion deal
Reuters - 5:17 PM ET 3/23/2025
-
Fibre-cement maker James Hardie to acquire outdoor products maker AZEK Co for $8.8 billion
Reuters - 4:38 PM ET 3/23/2025
-
Soccer-Man United thump Villa, leaders Chelsea beat Man City in Women's Super League
Reuters - 2:49 PM ET 3/23/2025
-
US education secretary praises Columbia's reforms to unlock $400 million
Reuters - 2:41 PM ET 3/23/2025
-
Iraq plans to raise oil production capacity above 6 million bpd by 2029
Reuters - 8:05 AM ET 3/23/2025