Have you ever made a money decision you regretted? If the answer is no, congrats—bet you floss every day too, you rock star. On the other hand, if you still cringe over a past money move, you’re not alone. In 2022, 76% of Americans reported making at least one financial mistake, according to a Credit Karma survey.1
We asked 4 real people to share their past financial problems, so you can learn their lessons without feeling the pain yourself.
1. Co-signing for a friend who didn’t repay the loan
When Molly Watters was a 25-year-old graduate student, a close friend came to her with a question: Would she co-sign a $10,000 student loan? Watters, now 40 and living in Hollywood, MD, says she thought about it carefully. “I’m someone who says I would do anything for a friend, and here she was asking me to do something for her. So I figured, ‘I’m going to do it,’” says Watters. They discussed that payments, which would start immediately, had to be paid on time. Watters says her friend paid $10 each month faithfully until she graduated in 2010. Then, when the monthly payments went up to $125, she simply stopped paying.
Not only did this money mistake cause an irreparable rift in the friendship, Watters found herself dealing with it for more than a decade. Watters protected her credit by making on-time payments until the loan was paid off in 2022—and walked away with an important lesson: “If you co-sign for someone, you’re stuck paying it off if they don’t,” she says. “So be very careful before making that kind of commitment.”
2. Borrowing from future you for a wedding
Bethany Marlatt, 36, wishes she had more financial education, too, before she and her husband made their own money mistake. The couple, who live in Sugar Grove, IL, were planning their wedding and finding it difficult to pay for everything with cash. They had already run up high-interest credit card debt and were paying off a car loan at 26% interest, due to a low credit score.
“We had intended to save up for our wedding, but the budget was just spiraling out of control,” she says. So the couple took a 2-year, $10,000 loan against her husband’s 401(k) to pay wedding bills. Though opting for a loan rather than withdrawing the money outright saved them from penalties and fees, it still impacted their retirement planning, as they missed out on several years of potential tax-free investment growth. The wedding was beautiful, but Marlatt says she wouldn’t recommend doing what she did. “I don't think we understood how important it was to save for retirement until we were older.”
Read more about the tradeoffs and other considerations before taking out a 401(k) loan.
3. Moving in with a partner without a written agreement
Ten years ago, Misti Nippert, 40, and her fiancé decided to rent a house together in Hendersonville, TN. But when the couple experienced problems, Nippert asked her fiancé to move out. Although he was listed on the lease, her fiancé immediately stopped paying rent and refused to pay thousands of dollars in damages his dog caused.
Between window replacements, carpet cleaning, and 4 months of rent, Nippert owed $17,000. She emptied her savings account but still couldn’t pay everything, so she took a high-interest loan and borrowed money from her father. “It took me 2 years to recover from that,” she says. “Now I wouldn’t go into any type of rental or home purchase with someone unless I could afford 100% of the rent or mortgage on my own salary. And that includes all the utilities.”
Among other tips when moving in with a partner, it’s important to discuss how expenses will be covered including what happens if you split up. Consider putting that agreement in writing—beyond co-signing a lease—just in case. This could give you a stronger position should you have to take legal action to recoup your money.
4. Taking on too much student debt compared to future income
Katie Munizza, 35, a part-time occupational therapist from Abington, PA, attended school on and off for 10 years—in part because she switched majors along the way. She borrowed both federal and private student loans to finance her education, and by 2016—after earning 2 associate degrees and being one class away from a bachelor’s degree—she owed more than $100,000. Today, she still owes about $78,000.
Munizza has hustled to pay down her loans by working 2 jobs, but she says she wishes she had done more research before spending so much time and money on degrees that didn’t set her up to earn a lot.
Student loans can be an important tool for gaining access to higher education, and nearly 1 in 4 adults with a bachelor’s degree or higher have at least some student debt.2 But prospective students should understand how much their potential salary could be—or could increase to—and how that compares to their loan amount and future payments. Just like any investment, it’s important to calculate the ROI (return on investment) of taking out a student loan.